Truck Trend Homepage

Road Test Comparison: 2007 BMW X5 and 2007 Land Rover Discovery 3


It's rated at 188-190 horsepower at 4000 rpm, depending on which rating system you use, and approximately 325 pound-feet of torque at 1900 rpm. The 2.7 diesel makes more peak torque than the 4.4-liter gas engine, but, far more importantly, it delivers close to 300 pound-feet from 1500-3000 rpm where it's most frequently operated. The comparable 4.4-liter needs close to 3200 rpm to approach 300 pound-feet.


Manufacturer figures show diesel fuel consumption (with the automatic) as roughly 50 percent better than the 4.4-liter V-8's, the biggest gain in the city cycle, and the manual gearbox enjoys an even larger advantage (no manual is offered with the V-8). This is a primary reason diesel has market penetration near 80 percent for SUVs over the pond. The diesel also has significantly lower CO2 emissions.

Unless it sat overnight in subfreezing temperatures (when it needed four seconds for preheat), the D3 diesel started up immediately and idled smoothly. At idle with fans and radio off, you can tell it's a diesel, or perhaps a gas engine with noisy injectors or tappets, but once accessories are on and you're moving it's comfortably quiet. According to Land Rover literature, drive-by noise is 70.8 dB on a diesel auto and the V-8 is louder (72.7).

Drop the TDV6 in Drive and as soon as the torque converter goes to work, low-end urge is apparent. Plenty of throttle travel means you hardly need revised mapping in low-range or specific Terrain Response modes, and even if you floor it from a stop, the turbo spools up to take out any hard hit. That initial delay might cost half a second in all-out blasts, but it's not noticed underway, and using Sport mode doesn't make it faster at wide-open throttle. At full throttle the engine goes past horsepower peak and off boost slightly, resulting in luxo-smooth shifts rather than blunt and harsh.


The D3 goes like any diesel and most previous Land Rovers: it gathers momentum rather than accelerating. Our hand-timed jaunts to 62 mph (100 kph) averaged 11.6 seconds, a tenth better than factory claims and about 3.0 seconds behind a gas V-8. Top speed is listed as 112 mph (180 kph, in fifth or sixth gear) though we had no trouble making the needle climb to 188, nearly keeping up with air traffic approaching the adjacent airport.


Prev  | 1  | 2  | 3  | 4  | Next
New Truck Price Quote
Get FREE, up-front new vehicle pricing and a no hassle buying experience.

RELATED PHOTOS

2007 Bmw X5 3.0D 3.0l I6 Engine 2007 Land Rover Discovery 3 2.7l Tdv6 Engine 2007 Bmw X5 3.0D Front View
2007 Bmw X5 3.0D Front Side View 2007 Land Rover Discovery 3 Front Side View 2007 Land Rover Discovery 3 Front View

2008 Jeep Wrangler Rubicon: One of the most credible names in 4x4 gets tougher

Posted July 18 2008 10:31 AM by Mark Williams
If there's any name synonymous with four-wheel-drive capability, it's Jeep. And if there's any question about which Jeep is the most capable player on the team, there shouldn't be. The Wrangler has long been the ultimate...  more

Review and Reach of my own: RECARO Young Sport toddler car seat

  Just recently, I've "volunteered" to help my younger sister with the responsibility of taking my almost two-year-old nephew to daycare for her in the mornings. This has opened an whole new world of questions about safety,...more  

You're Buying WOT? $42,875 Hard-core SUVs

  You think of the recent spike in gas prices not as a deterrent to buying a gas-hungry SUV, but as incentive to get the hard-core SUV of your dreams for a great price. The market is still full of choices to satiate your...more  

Must-See Truck Movies: When trucks turn into movie stars

  There are excellent movies that feature trucks prominently in the story line. Truck Trend ran John Pearly Huffman's " Top 10 Truck Movies " in the March/April 2007 issue. As with all lists, there's bound to be...more  

Life of a Salesman: Chery lawsuit latest turn for entrepreneur Bricklin

  I could see the train wreck coming when I interviewed Malcolm Bricklin a couple of years ago for the November 2005 issue of Motor Trend. His company, Visionary Vehicles, had signed a deal with Chery Automobile Company,...more  

 
LAnd Rover marketing campaign Bad idea?
We recently discovered this article from Brandweek/Adweek about a new marketing campaign for Land... more
 
who would you choose: 2007 BMW X3 and 2008 Land Rover LR2
Has anyone actually driven an X3 much less at in one? The interior quality is atrocious, it has a... more
 
Nice Little Piece on Auto Recalls
Most-Recalled Cars... more
 
SUVs That Stretch Fuel Dollars
SUVs That Stretch Fuel DollarsFord Escape Hybrid, Saturn Vue Green Line Rated Best Among Small,... more