Truck Trend Homepage

Road Test Comparison: 2007 BMW X5 and 2007 Land Rover Discovery 3

Diesel Duo: 510 Miles on a Tank of Fuel!

By G.R. Whale
Photography by the Manufacturers

With a few formally announced diesel-powered SUVs that are due in the U.S. by 2008 and a Grand Cherokee diesel shown at Detroit, it appears the diesel is gaining ground. To see what Europe may have to offer in the growing diesel battle, we went to Germany to drive a diesel BMW X5 and Land Rover Discovery3 (aka LR3), neither of which have been announced for sale in the U.S., but you never know what may be coming.

BMW and Land Rover have had diesel power in North America before, BMW with the 524td sedan and Land Rover with Defenders for the military. We expect a BMW diesel here by 2008, probably a thirsty premium vehicle. In the meantime, the best we can do is to head to Europe to drive the X5 and Discovery3.


Our examples were automatics; market research suggests they'd sell better than those equipped with manuals. Apart from slight changes to lights and bumpers, instruments, snow tires (the same size and speed rating as standard), perhaps slightly stiffer spring rates, intercoolers behind the grilles, and exhaust systems, the X5 pipes come out below the rear valance, not through it--they're similar to North American units.

Quieter Than Gas
When we first turned the key on the Discovery3, our eyes focused on the instruments, looking for a glow plug or wait-to-start indication. What stood out instead was a gauge indicating a whopping 820 kilometers' range on the tank. This equals just under 510 miles. Even using fingers for the math this was way more than any benzene-burning LR3 ever gave us.


The TDV6, the diesel version of the Discovery3, uses a PSA/Ford-developed 2.7-liter V-6. An iron-block, aluminum-head twin-cam with four valves per cylinder and common-rail injection, the Land Rover variant uses a single variable nozzle turbo and, as would be expected, the oiling system and seals are modified for extreme-angle off-road use.


1  | 2  | 3  | 4  | Next
New Truck Price Quote
Get FREE, up-front new vehicle pricing and a no hassle buying experience.

RELATED PHOTOS

2007 Bmw X5 3.0D 3.0l I6 Engine 2007 Land Rover Discovery 3 2.7l Tdv6 Engine 2007 Bmw X5 3.0D Front View
2007 Bmw X5 3.0D Front Side View 2007 Land Rover Discovery 3 Front Side View 2007 Land Rover Discovery 3 Front View

Moab Madness: Jeep and Hummer doing it right

Posted May 5 2008 08:24 AM by Mark Williams
Much of our time is spent traveling places to drive a given manufacturer's latest and greatest. Usually that means flying to some familiar place, staying is some familiar hotel, and more times than not driving on some...  more

Refreshing or Revolting -- 2009 Subaru Forester

  Subaru has redesigned its Forester crossover for 2009 and already the SUV has placed first in our tough test of compact crossovers. The Forester may have improved functionally, but are you digging the new look or do you...more  

Driving an SUV? Trade it in now, while you still can

  Has the ever-growing pain at the pump finally gotten you thinking about giving up your V-8, seven-passenger SUV for something a little more frugal? Well you might want to get to a dealership soon, because the trade-in...more  

GM Full-Size Hybrid SUVs: Too Many Stinking Badges

  I congratulate General Motors for being first in the pool with hybrid-powered, full-size sport/utilities. These SUVs employ a true hybrid powertrain (not like the Malibu, Aura, and previous-gen GM trucks, which use what...more  

Kill the gas tax moratorium proposals

  DETROIT - This is an idea whose time has come, and quickly gone. Presidential candidates John McCain (I believe he proposed it first, so he's mentioned first) and Hillary Clinton have proposed a moratorium on the federal...more  

LAnd Rover marketing campaign Bad idea?
We recently discovered this article from Brandweek/Adweek about a new marketing campaign for Land... more
who would you choose: 2007 BMW X3 and 2008 Land Rover LR2
Has anyone actually driven an X3 much less at in one? The interior quality is atrocious, it has a... more
Nice Little Piece on Auto Recalls
Most-Recalled Cars"... more
SUVs That Stretch Fuel Dollars
SUVs That Stretch Fuel DollarsFord Escape Hybrid, Saturn Vue Green Line Rated Best Among Small,... more