Truck Trend Homepage

Road Test Comparison: 2007 BMW X5 and 2007 Land Rover Discovery 3


For perspective, that acceleration puts the D3 diesel soundly in H3 territory and a fraction to one second slower than an Escape V-6, Liberty CRD, H2, and Prius. None of those weighs 5500 pounds and none carries seven people; we're not convinced they can all do 112 mph, either, and shorter gearing would likely make a TDV6 brisker with next to no penalty in fuel economy.

At a steady 65 mph, the TDV6 computer displayed an average fuel use of 29.8 mpg, and despite our repeated top-speed verification, acceleration runs, generally driving exactly the opposite you should in a three-ton 4WD, and less-then-ideal conditions, typically in 30-degree wet weather, fully loaded, we still averaged more than 20 mpg. In city stop-and-go or less aggressive use, we'd expect close to 25 overall.


The Ultimate Diesel Machine?
One might argue that BMW knows as much about diesels as Mercedes, having brought one to the U.S. market, offering them in every sedan (even the long-wheelbase 7 Series), and entering a twin-turbo diesel in the Paris-Dakar rally.

BMW makes more than one 3.0-liter turbodiesel and multiple ratings. This second-generation unit has an aluminum block and head with a single turbo, EGR, and diesel catalyst. Ratings are about 214 U.S. horsepower at 4000 rpm and 368 pound-feet of torque from 2000 through 2750 rpm, again comparable torque at lower rpm than the 4.4-liter gasoline V-8 choice.

A handheld stopwatch recorded 0-to-62 mph in 8.74 seconds while the trip computer's stopwatch gave us the same 8.8 that BMW quotes for the automatic. This is about one second slower than an X5 3.0 gas engine we tested in 2002, but that X5 benefited from a manual gearbox (with 5.09:1 first and direct-drive fifth) and 4.10:1 gears; the diesel tested had 3.91:1 gears that, like the D3, might sensibly be swapped for something a bit shorter for the North American market. Top speed is given as 210 kph (close to 130 mph), an indication that proved easy to reach unless the snow dictated slowing down. A certain amusement comes from driving at top speed with a trip computer showing mileage in the teens, whether or not it's precise.


BMW's gas 3.0-liter carries EPA ratings of 15/21, and we were able to record 19.8 on one highway cruise. The 3.0-liter diesel, routinely tested in city traffic or close to its top speed, roughly twice as fast as the gas tester, averaged better than 21 mpg. Official figures give the diesel a 50-percent economy advantage in the urban cycle and a smaller gain in the city; CO2 values are similarly lower.


Prev  | 1  | 2  | 3  | 4  | Next
New Truck Price Quote
Get FREE, up-front new vehicle pricing and a no hassle buying experience.

RELATED PHOTOS

2007 Bmw X5 3.0D 3.0l I6 Engine 2007 Land Rover Discovery 3 2.7l Tdv6 Engine 2007 Bmw X5 3.0D Front View
2007 Bmw X5 3.0D Front Side View 2007 Land Rover Discovery 3 Front Side View 2007 Land Rover Discovery 3 Front View

2008 Jeep Wrangler Rubicon: One of the most credible names in 4x4 gets tougher

Posted July 18 2008 10:31 AM by Mark Williams
If there's any name synonymous with four-wheel-drive capability, it's Jeep. And if there's any question about which Jeep is the most capable player on the team, there shouldn't be. The Wrangler has long been the ultimate...  more

Reader's Letters: Time to stop Playing

  I enjoyed your article in the May/June 2008 issue, " Time To Play ," by Larry Walton. While I like to read about the new toys available and I liked the pictures, I didn't expect to see this kind of story in a magazine...more  

Video Find: IIHS tests small pickups for the first time; Tacoma best rated

  In recent side crash tests conducted by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, the 2008 Toyota Tacoma earned the highest rating while the Dodge Dakota, Ford Ranger, and Nissan Frontier faired "okay" and the and the...more  

Review and Reach of my own: RECARO Young Sport toddler car seat

  Just recently, I've "volunteered" to help my younger sister with the responsibility of taking my almost two-year-old nephew to daycare for her in the mornings. This has opened an whole new world of questions about safety,...more  

You're Buying WOT? $42,875 Hard-core SUVs

  You think of the recent spike in gas prices not as a deterrent to buying a gas-hungry SUV, but as incentive to get the hard-core SUV of your dreams for a great price. The market is still full of choices to satiate your...more  

 
LAnd Rover marketing campaign Bad idea?
We recently discovered this article from Brandweek/Adweek about a new marketing campaign for Land... more
 
who would you choose: 2007 BMW X3 and 2008 Land Rover LR2
Has anyone actually driven an X3 much less at in one? The interior quality is atrocious, it has a... more
 
Nice Little Piece on Auto Recalls
Most-Recalled Cars By Dan Lienert Last week, Honda Motor announced a global recall of 45,000 Civic... more
 
SUVs That Stretch Fuel Dollars
SUVs That Stretch Fuel DollarsFord Escape Hybrid, Saturn Vue Green Line Rated Best Among Small,... more