Winner: Ford F-150 SuperCrew
Runner-Up: Toyota Tundra CrewMax

This is the most varied (and largest) pickup-truck segment, making the choice of best in class one of the most difficult. We had to pick from compact, midsize, and full-size trucks, including some based on SUV platforms. To make a decision here, we followed the same rules as we do with our Truck of the Year event: We compare each candidate with the rest of its competitive set to see which does the best job. And this year, the Ford F-150 SuperCrew gets the nod. It still offers the best towing capacity, incredible versatility across the line, and top-notch interiors (with a flat floor in the SuperCrew's second row). Those who are shopping for a crew cab have so many choices here, it would be very easy to get the exact truck you need--and make sure it's the one you want, too, without breaking the bank. The Tundra CrewMax is a close second, as the new standard V-8 engine available for 2010 has more power and provides better fuel economy than the one it replaces.

Which would you choose as your 2010 Best in Class Crew Cab Pickup, 2WD?

  • Chevy Colorado
  • GMC Canyon
  • Chevy Silverado
  • GMC Sierra
  • Chevy Avalanche
  • Dodge Dakota Crew Cab
  • Ford Explorer Sport Trac
  • Ford F-150 SuperCrew
  • Honda Ridgeline AWD
  • Nissan Frontier
  • Nissan Titan
  • Ram 1500 Crew Cab
  • Toyota Tacoma
  • Toyota Tundra CrewMax
See Results

Don't agree with our winner? Then tell us which vehicle would you have picked as the 2010 Best in Class Crew Cab Pickup, 2WD in the comment box below.


Crew Cab Pickup, 2WD -- A to F
Vehicle Chevy/GMC Colorado/ Canyon Chevy/GMC Silverado/ Sierra Chevy Avalanche
Base price $24,565/$24,655 $30,370/$30,370 $36,675
Wheelbase 126.0 in 143.5 in 130.0 in
Engine 2.9L DOHC I-4 4.8L OHV V-8 5.3L OHV V-8
Opt engines 3.7L V-6 $1000, 5.3L V-8 $2300 5.3L V-8 $800, 6.2L V-8 $5925  
Power, SAE 185 hp (242, 300) 302 hp (315, 403) 310 hp
Torque, SAE 190 lb-ft (242, 320) 305 lb-ft (338, 417) 335 lb-ft
Airbags Front, f/r curt Front, f side, f/r curt Fr, f side, f/r curt
Brakes, f/r Disc/drum, ABS Disc/drum, ABS Disc/disc, ABS
Tires 235/75R16 245/70R17 265/70R17
Fuel cap 19.6 gal 26.0 gal 31.0 gal
EPA fuel econ, 18/25 mpg (17/23, 15/20) 14/19 mpg (15/21-22, 13/19) 15/21 mpg
Seating cap 6 6 6
Curb weight 3688 lb 5176 lb 5478 lb
GVWR 5000 lb 6800 lb 7000 lb
Payload 1250 lb 1924 lb 1320 lb
Max towing cap 6000 lb 10,600 lb 8100 lb
 
Vehicle Dodge Dakota Crew Cab Ford Explorer Sport Trac Ford F-150 SuperCrew
Base price $26,045 $29,025 $30,030
Wheelbase 131.3 in 130.5 in 144.5 in
Engine 3.7L SOHC V-6 4.0L SOHC V-6 4.6L SOHC 2V V-8
Opt engines 4.7L V-8 $2400 4.6L 3V V-8 $6165 4.6L 3V V-8 $945, 5.4L V-8 $3760
Power, SAE 210 hp (302) 210 hp (292) 248 hp (292, 315)
Torque, SAE 235 lb-ft (329) 254 lb-ft (315) 294 lb-ft (320, 365)
Airbags Front Fr, f side, f/r curt Fr, f side, f/r curt
Brakes, f/r Disc/drum, ABS Disc/disc, ABS Disc/disc, ABS
Tires 245/70R16 235/70R16 235/70R17
Fuel cap 22.0 gal 22.5 gal 26.0 gal
EPA fuel econ, city/hwy 15/20 mpg (14/19) 14/20 mpg (15/21) 15/19 mpg (15/21, 14/20)
Seating cap 6 5 5
Curb weight 4336 lb 4673 lb 5137 lb
GVWR 6010 lb 6100 lb 7100 lb
Payload 1670 lb 1380 lb 1750 lb
Max towing cap 7050 lb 7160 lb 11,300 lb

Crew Cab Pickup, 2WD -- H to Z
Vehicle Honda Ridgeline AWD Nissan Frontier Nissan Titan
Base price $29,160 $23,090 $29,670
Wheelbase 122.0 in 125.9 in 139.8 in
Engine 3.5L SOHC V-6 4.0L DOHC V-6 5.6L DOHC V-8
Opt engines      
Power, SAE 250 hp 261 hp 317 hp
Torque, SAE 247 lb-ft 281 lb-ft 385 lb-ft
Airbags Fr, f side, f/r curt Front, f side Front, f side
Brakes, f/r Disc/disc, ABS Disc/disc, ABS Disc/disc, ABS
Tires 245/65R17 265/70R16 265/70R18
Fuel cap 22.0 gal 21.1 gal 28.0 gal
EPA fuel econ, city/hwy 15/20 mpg 16/20 mpg 13/18 mpg
Seating cap 5 5 6
Curb weight 4504 lb 4282 lb 5049 lb
GVWR 6050 lb 5690 lb 7100 lb
Payload 1546 lb 1408 lb 2014 lb
Max towing cap 5000 lb 6300 lb 9400 lb
 
Vehicle Ram 1500 Crew Cab Toyota Tacoma Toyota Tundra CrewMax
Base price $29,520 $24,475 $29,715
Wheelbase 140.5 in 127.4 in 145.7 in
Engine 4.7L SOHC V-8 4.0L DOHC V-6 4.6L DOHC V-8
Opt engines 5.7L V-8 $1310   5.7L V-8 $1300
Power, SAE 310 hp (390) 236 hp 310 hp (381)
Torque, SAE 330 lb-ft (407) 266 lb-ft 327 lb-ft (401)
Airbags Fr, f side, f/r curt Fr, f/r curt Fr, f side, f/r curt, knee
Brakes, f/r Disc/disc, ABS Disc/drum, ABS Disc/disc, ABS
Tires 265/70R17 245/75R16 255/70R18
Fuel cap 26.0 gal 21.0 gal 26.4 gal
EPA fuel econ, city/hwy 14/19 mpg (14/20) 17/21 mpg 15/20 mpg (14/18)
Seating cap 6 5 6
Curb weight 5054 lb 3920 lb 5250 lb
GVWR 6800 lb 5350 lb 7000 lb
Payload 1690 lb 1440 lb 1665 lb
Max towing cap 10,200 lb 6500 lb 10,400 lb
  • «
  • |
  • 1
  • |
  • 2
  • |
  • 3
  • |
  • View Full Article