Truck Trend Homepage
Truck Trend
2011 Ford F 250 2010 Dodge Ram 2500 Front Three Quarter

Comparison: 2011 Ford F-250 Super Duty vs 2010 Ram 2500 HD

Outstanding in their Field: Can Dearborn's Biggest and Newest Match the 2010 Truck of the Year?
From the June, 2010 issue of Truck Trend
By Mark Williams
Photography by Julia LaPalme
 

2011 Ford F 250 2010 Dodge Ram 2500 Front Three Quarter Front View
The battle lines have been redrawn. Ford and Dodge (now Ram) have been duking it out with each other in the heavy-duty (3/4- and one-ton) pickup market for what seems like forever, but in recent times Ford has been winning the biggest percentage of market share while the Ram HD has the highest all-important diesel take rate in the segment, almost 85 percent. These trucks are made for hard work and hard play. And even though sales for full-size pickups have dropped as much as 40 percent in some segments, OEs understand there will always be buyers for work trucks. And here we've decided to pit two of the latest -- the all-new 2011 Ford Super Duty and the Ram 2500 HD -- head to head, equipped with the all-important oil-burner. Diesel connoisseurs have been waiting for this confrontation for ages. The 2010.5 federal emissions regulations essentially forced all three of the 3/4- and one-ton work-truck makers to dig deep and come up with clever ways to provide the most pulling power possible with a much cleaner NOx and particulate emissions rating. The 350-horsepower, 650-pound-foot 6.7-liter Cummins I-6 was updated three years ago and was the first of the HD diesel engines to meet the stricter 2010.5 regulations. Unlike the Cummins, Ford's all-new 6.7-liter, 390-horse, 735-pound-foot V-8 Power Stroke (now built in-house) uses a urea-based aftertreatment emissions system.

Diesel connoisseurs have been waiting for this confrontation for ages. The 2010.5 federal emissions regulations essentially forced all three of the 3/4- and one-ton work-truck makers to dig deep and come up with clever ways to provide the most pulling power possible with a much cleaner NOx and particulate emissions rating. The 350-horsepower, 650-pound-foot 6.7-liter Cummins I-6 was updated three years ago and was the first of the HD diesel engines to meet the stricter 2010.5 regulations. Unlike the Cummins, Ford's all-new 6.7-liter, 390-horse, 735-pound-foot V-8 Power Stroke (now built in-house) uses a urea-based aftertreatment emissions system.

2011 Ford F 250 2010 Dodge Ram 2500 Front Three Quarter
2011 Ford F 250 2010 Dodge Ram 2500 Front Three Quarter View
2011 Ford F 250 2010 Dodge Ram 2500 Rear Three Quarter View

1  | 2  | 3  | 4  | 5  | 6  | Next

RELATED PHOTOS

2010 Dodge Ram 2500 Front Passengers Side View 2010 Dodge Ram 2500 Front View
2010 Dodge Ram 2500 Front Drivers Side View 2010 Dodge Ram 2500 Drivers Side Front
Recent Articles

More Related Content

Community Comments

buddyIam  (04/11/10 09:23 PM)

How much urea per mile was used by the ford. Doesn't this also have to be figured in if you are to make an even comparison of the vehicals MPG?

vanman987  (04/15/10 08:45 PM)

I just want to know if anyone has done the math and can tell me if unclogging the exhaust and allowing a diesel to breath and get better MPG's might be better for the environment, then choking them down? I'm sure that I read on the National Bio Diesel Board website that a clean running standard diesel of even 2 or 3 years ago gives off less pollution than it's gas counterpart. Then mix in as little as a 5 percent solution of bio-fuel and that is even cut further. Maybe even to or past the point that no urea need be used or even a cat converter. But I'm sure someone will come up with a bypass for the urea. Just some programming and maybe a spliced wire or two. But then you'd also have to cut off the exhaust and I'm sure that would get you stopped also. Maybe you could just cut the guts out and put it back on. Love to see the mileage then. Wouldn't it be awful for a full-size truck to get say 30 mpg with just a bit more exhaust. Plant a couple extra trees every year and the circle of life is complete.

vFeralLynXv  (01/27/11 05:21 PM)

Both great trucks. Another great review.

agaparts2012  (09/03/11 12:48 PM)

both great, but i think that ford is better!

Post a Comment (Must Be Registered)



*Please enter your username

*Please enter your password

*Please enter your comments
User Name
Not Registered? Signup Here
Password
Comment
   (1024 character limit)
Trade In Value