Truck Trend Homepage

Truck Trend's Second Annual Ultimate 4x4 Challenge

Six contenders, three days, 1344 miles, two cases of whiplash, and one winner

By Scott Mead
Photography by the author, Brian Vance

Tow straps--check. Fix-a-Flat: half a dozen cans...where's that portable air compressor? Water? A couple cases should do the trick, and don't forget a case of sport drinks, a box of energy bars, and the first-aid kit. Facing our team was a three-day flogging of the best off-roaders on the market today: the old-school grunt and mechanical lockers found in the traditionally crafted Dodge Ram Power Wagon, Hummer H3, and Toyota Land Cruiser against the techno-wizardry in the Jeep Grand Cherokee, Land Rover LR3, and Volkswagen Touareg. With our supplies in order and fuel tanks filled, we left the security of the city for the California desert. Services would be minimal, cellular service spotty at best, and mistakes could be costly.

The Getaway
Busting loose from the office and rolling along the freeway to our favorite SVRA haunt, our radios started to crackle with comments of on-road behavior. We heard tell of the throaty roar and wide torque band from the Power Wagon's Hemi V-8. The Dodge was fortified with a suspension to take a pounding on the rocks, and the truck's ride was equally punishing on the highway, with axle hop at times becoming downright violent. The polar opposite was reported from the Touareg, especially when the air suspension was in Comfort mode, which effectively quelled most road irregularities.

Quick Links

Off-Road Traction Tech

Specifications: Dodge Ram Power Wagon, Hummer H3, and Jeep Grand Cherokee

Specifications: Land Rover LR3, Toyota Land Cruiser, and Volkswagen Touareg

Finishing Order

The Great Slide

Word came from the Toyota: Novocain-laced steering and high crosswinds make straight-line driving a challenge; also heard was a wish that the Land Cruiser's interior were as up to date as sibling Sequoia. Meanwhile, claustrophobia was setting in behind the wheel of the H3, and concerns arose that its box-with-cut-out-viewing-ports design might pose an issue when cresting hills. Our driver further noted that the I-5 seemed barely up to our highway-speed (with crosswinds) needs.

The Grand Cherokee passed the group in the left lane, its Hemi V-8 in full song, the driver radioing that the Jeep was incredibly poised in the corners, had oodles of power, and sported the best interior ever placed in a Jeep product. The editor in the LR3 begged to differ, citing the Rover's commodious cabin, supple suspension, and a 4.4-liter V-8 that plugs along at a buck-thirty without breaking a sweat.

Arriving at Hungry Valley SVRA, we headed to the off-road training course, where we could prep our novice drivers and tackle a few obstacles under controlled conditions.


1  | 2  | 3  | 4  | 5  | 6  | 7  | 8  | 9  | 10  | 11  | 12  | 13  | Next
New Truck Price Quote
Get FREE, up-front new vehicle pricing and a no hassle buying experience.

RELATED PHOTOS

Hummer H3 Front Passenger Side View Jumping A Sand Dune Toyota Land Cruiser Front Passenger Side View Playing In The Sand Jeep Grand Cherokee Drivers Side Front Nose View
Hummer H3 Rear Drivers Side View Rock Climbing Toyota Land Cruiser Rear Drivers Side View Rock Crawling Jeep Grand Cherokee Rear Passenger Side View Rock Crawling

Breaking Hummer from the Mothership will take a huge hammer

Posted August 18 2008 02:15 PM by Mark Williams
There's no shortage of speculation about Hummer. In that regard, nothing's changed. From Day One of the “gentleman's agreement” between companies, there were journalists and car guys screaming that GM should get rid of...  more

2009 Motor Trend Sport/Utility of the Year: This year's players a diverse group

  The 2009 Motor Trend Sport Utility of the Year judging is underway, and we're testing, poking, prodding, and otherwise flogging this year's field of 13 contenders. It's a diverse bunch, which reflects the way the...more  

You're Buying WOT? $32,123 Seven-passenger Crossovers

  A Toyota Prius will not get your five-kid carpool to school legally (or in comfort), so your overzealous greenie neighbors will just need to deal with the seven-passenger crossover soon to fill your driveway. You're not...more  

Audi Q7 TDI spotted roaming Detroit

  We've been on the trail of the Audi Q7 TDI for some time now, and it's been tough to track. Audi has been very coy about when the clean diesel will hit our shores, how much it will cost, and just about any other details...more  

1991 Chevy Silverado for sale

  Remember the guy who posted his 1991 Chevy Silverado that had over one-million miles on eBay and wanted $30,000 for it? He’s back. more  

 
Volkswagen And Red Bull Team up for Baja 500
VOLKSWAGEN AND RED BULL PARTNER FOR THE 39th ANNUAL TECATE SCORE BAJA 500- Volkswagen and Red Bull... more